Sunday, June 29, 2014


Billmire (2).jpg

                    By Dr. David A. Billmire 

Opinion: There is no need for pit bulls

As one who, for the last 30 years, has been on the receiving end of the dog-bite injuries that pass through the Children's Hospital Emergency Room, as well as on the staff at the Shriners Hospitals for Children where we see the late effects of these injuries from across the nation, I can categorically tell you that the problems associated with dog bites are indeed breed-specific. When I started my career, the most common dog-bite injuries were from German shepherds and occasionally retrievers. 

These injuries were almost always provoked, such as food-related or stepping on the dog, and in almost every instance, the dog reacted with a single snap and release – essentially a warning shot. There were no pack attacks.

Starting about 25 years ago, my colleagues and I started to see disturbingly different types of injuries. Instead of a warning bite, we saw wounds where the flesh was torn from the victim. There were multiple bite wounds covering many different anatomical sites. The attacks were generally unprovoked, persistent and often involved more than one dog. In every instance the dog involved was a pit bull or a pit bull mix.

Now, I am a dog lover and virtually every one of my family members has a dog. But it is a fact that different dogs have always been bred for specific qualities. My sheltie herded, my daughter's setter flushes birds and my pug sits on my lap – this is what they are bred for. Pit bulls were bred to fight and kill and, unfortunately, many current breeders favor these aggressive traits. There is no need for any dog with the characteristics.

I recently gave a talk summarizing my 30 years of practice in pediatric plastic and reconstructive surgery, and one segment was titled "Why I Hate Pit Bulls." I watched a child bleed to death one night in our operating room because a pit bull had torn his throat out. I have had to rebuild the skull of a child who had his ears and entire scalp torn off. I am currently reconstructing the face of a child, half of whose face has been torn off down to the bone. I have had to rebuild noses, lips, eyelids, jaws and cheeks of numerous children. On older children, I have had to reconstruct legs and hands. The unfortunate young victim whose recent attack has initiated this discussion will bear the scars of this attack for the rest of her life.

Based on my extensive experience, I believe that the risk posed by pit bulls is equivalent to placing a loaded gun with the safety off on the coffee table. In my opinion, these dogs should be banned. I know this is an unpopular stand in some circles, but how many mauled children do we have to see before we realize the folly of allowing these dogs to exist?

The arguments made by advocates of these dogs are the same arguments made by people who feel that assault weapons are an essential part of daily living. There are plenty of breeds available that peacefully coexist with human society. There is no need for pit bulls.




Dayna Hamilton said...

It is so heartening to see people like him stand up publicly and speak out, sad that he has gotten to the point in his career that he feels he must do this, but it gives me hope that he has.

Anonymous said...

May God protect this man for speaking the truth.

Farmer Jane said...

It is so good to hear a professional with real experience speak the truth in a manner that can't be disputed. However, his gun analogy was not quite apt. A gun still needs a person to pick it up and fire it. A pit, as we all know, needs no help in going off.
I wish more professionals, ER docs, EMT's, law enforcement, et al., would speak up in a manner that can be heard. The horrors they must witness that are caused by pit bulls must be worthy of comment. But all we hear are the whiny, self-righteous diatribes of the nutters.They drown out all else. The victims and the witnesses need a bigger voice.

Farmer Jane said...

Here's one more thing and then I'll shut up for a while. Shriner's Hospital offers free medical care for children with severe injuries. It is a shame that they have to spend their money and services on the results of pit bull attacks. I am glad that they are there for the victims, who need all the help they can get. However, if the pits weren't there, and the attacks never happened, their resources would not have to be spent on the results of someone's choice of a pet. These animals are costing our society much more than they are worth.

Anonymous said...

Farmer Jane, please don't shut up for a while! You bring much knowledge to the table, and your input is invaluable.

Doctor Billmire speaks the truth. It needs to be said, it needs to be repeated, it needs to be accepted.

Pit bulls serve no purpose that regular dogs cannot fulfill.